Do we need more stuff? Or consider the buy nothing challenge from 2005

 
 
'Our economic model needs fixing. We need to change the social logic of consumption. Designers can contribute by developing and offering viable alternatives to the culture of consumerism.'
 
 
 
 

1. YOU'RE IN THE MIDDLE

By now, you must have received a zillion warning messages that human life on earth needs to quickly become more sustainable, or else. No more of that. Each page of this guide provides short and well-illustrated opportunities to help you participate in design for sustainability projects.

These themes are currently part of ongoing discussions at design schools, government institutions, and companies. The cluster of challenges seems overwhelming, but there’s a shimmer of light at the end of the tunnel. You’re lucky, because you’re now able to better participate in a pleasurable and rewarding activity: reducing humanity’s planetary harm.

This is not a call for action. You’ve already started.
 
 
 


Ivan Illich became known worldwide for his progressive polemics about how human culture could be preserved and expand, activity expressive of truly human values, in the face of multiple thundering forces of de-humanization. In his several influential books, he argued that the overuse of the benefits of many modern technologies and social arrangements undermine human values and human self-sufficiency, freedom, and dignity. His in-depth critiques of mass education and modern mass medicine were especially, pointed, relevant.

‘The average American puts in 1,600 hours to get 7,500 miles out of his car; that’s less than five miles per hour. In countries deprived of a transportation industry, people manage to do the same, walking wherever they want to go...’ (Ivan Illich).

 
 

ANCESTORS AND PEERS

The quest for a sustainable world is still young. Philosophers were the first to send out warning signals. Malthus expected huge shortages, Illich demonstrated that cars are slower than bicycles.

Many designers have addressed the potential of design for sustainability. They all want to make the world a better place. Best known: Viktor Papanek. He didn’t often use the word sustainability, but he saw what’s coming. Richard Buckminster Fuller, famous for his ideas of reduction said, ‘Use less and less to do more and more’. He was a technological progress visionary in the 20th century. There are many others. Trace them. Find the origins of the principles of reuse, recycling, and efficient energy conversion and storage.

Converse with peers, preferably in informal settings. One idea leads to the next. Talking never harmed anyone.
 

READ MORE >>

 
LINKS:
 
 

Victor Papanek's 1971 book 'Design for the real world' and the 2021 exhibition 'The politics of design'

 
 
 

2. BENCHMARKS

The only way to effectively approach sustainability is from a systems perspective. You need to consider a wide perspective before diving into details.

There are no ready-made design approaches that guide you through all that is important about sustainability. Instead, you must learn to patch together a series of different approaches, frameworks, and visions in order to build a sustainable solution. These are presented here as benchmarks. Use these to better understand and shape your own sustainable design process.

Some benchmarks clearly indicate what should be done and how to go about it, others are more ambiguous; they’ll help you reflect on your norms and values as a designer.

Sustainability is going to become more important as time passes. Work with these benchmarks. Choose the ones you like best and use them to improve your sustainable design skills. It will make you a better designer, if nothing else.
 
 
 


HANS ROSLING was a Swedish physician, academic, and public speaker. His research concerned other links between economic development, agriculture, poverty and health. With his son Ola he built the Trendalyzer software to animate data compiled by the UN and the World Bank that helped him explain the world with graphics. This made him worldfamous.

People often call me an optimist because I show them the enormous progress they didn’t know about. That makes me angry. I’m not an optimist. I’m a very serious ‘possibilist’. As a possibilist, I see all this progress and it fills me with conviction and hope that further progress is possible. This is not optimistic. It’s having a clear and reasonable idea about how things are. (Hans Rosling)

 
 

BIG PRACTICES

Apply benchmarks, but importantly, challenge them. Achieving sustainability is not a simple matter of ticking the right boxes. There’s no absolute ‘sustainable material’ or ‘sustainable product’. There are no final answers. Sustainability depends on worldviews, human behavior, and the project at hand.

To develop an overview, we offer crude, often-neglected guidelines. They can help put benchmarks in place, depending on what you’re working on.
  • Long timelines help define future tasks, so be prepared for decades to come. After the deadline, the lifeline starts.
  • Large scale projects are more likely to make a difference.
  • A sustainable option merely adds to existing ones. There will be more products and energy consumption than before so we need overruling alternatives to reduce the flows.
  • Bearing witness to sustainability improvement is not sufficient; get the evidence.
  • It takes more than awareness for people to change their behavior. Learn about social habits: consumers have them, companies have them, design studios have them, you have them. Social psychology provides principles for behavioral change.
  • Be wary of data processing devices. They’re not harmless.
 

READ MORE >>

 
LINKS:
 
 

United Nations Sustainable Development Goals

 
 
 

3. THE FORCE WE SERVE

The first law of thermo-dynamics states that energy can be converted in form, but it can neither be created nor destroyed. The unit of energy is the Joule, the amount of work needed to move an object over a distance of one meter with a force of one Newton.

Human civilization requires loads of energy to function which it gets from energy resources such as fossil fuels, nuclear fuel, or renewables. The processes of Earth’s climate and ecosystem are driven by the radiant energy Earth receives from the Sun and the geothermal energy contained within the earth.
 
 
 


The lithium-ion battery has powered us for decades. But for a renewable future, we need a new solution—and fast. So what are our options? The different kinds of thermal energy storage can be divided into three separate categories: sensible heat, latent heat, and thermo-chemical heat storage. Each of these has different advantages and disadvantages that determine their applications. How salt and sand could be used as durable and reliable energy storage.

The heat, which can be derived from a solar collector on a rooftop, expels the water contained in the salt. When the water is added again, the heat is released, with almost no energy losses. A container with a few cubic meters of salt could store enough of this thermochemical energy to heat a house throughout the winter. (Wikipedia)

 
 

2000 WATT FOR INSPIRATION

You must feel where this is going. The Transition without decreasing our energy consumption is unlikely to succeed. Many of us know this and propose to include lifestyle changes in the developmental necessities of the Transition.

By the end of the 1990’s In Switzerland a vision emerged: the 2000-Watt Society. Three goals were defined:
• Efficiency: use less energy for the same purpose
• Consistency: use renewable energy sources
• Sufficiency: use less for a better quality of life

The ideals are there. Yet the first two goals have the flavour of decoupling: Keep things as they are despite reduction in energy use. Future renewability of energy sources is assumed. But the third goal, sufficiency, defined as 2000 Watt per person is intriguing. Here we are heading for lifestyle changes.

Unmentioned are practical implications, such as lightweight or muscle-powered transportation, the bravado of a cold shower, special rules for non-essential items (as we’ve seen during Covid), conspicuous idleness, growing vegetables in the windowsill, staying close to home, rationing energy, getting physical, bringing handwritten letters personally, wrapping yourself in a gloriously warm wide onesie, Friday invention day, neighbourhood doorbell dancing mobs (who needs a phone anyway?).

List twenty more examples of a pleasant 2000-Watt life.
 

READ MORE >>

 
LINKS:
 
 


 
 
 

USEFULNESS

As soon as users lay their hands on products, the struggle for sustainability starts. They’re the ones that can make a difference, provided they get support from designers.

Becoming a savvy customer is really difficult; most of us have a sales victim background. Change requires a revision of nothing less than the assumptions behind growth.

The next step is to help users develop responsible behavior. The means for this are amply available. Applying them must become common sense.
 
 
 


Noam Chomsky (born December 7, 1928) is widely recognized as having helped to spark the cognitive revolution in the human sciences, contributing to the development of a new cognitivistic framework for the study of language and the mind. Chomsky remains a leading critic of contemporary capitalism and corporatocracy, which uses corporate media, advertising, and think tanks to promote its own propaganda.

Instead of citizens, neoliberal democracy produces consumers. Instead of communities, it produces shopping malls. The net result is an atomized society of disengaged individuals who feel demoralized and socially powerless. (Noam Chomsky)

 
 

NUDGING RULES INSTINCT

Once upon a time, there was a fairy tale theme park with many attractive rides. Yet it was best known for its garbage gobblers near the spots where you could get refreshments. They were larger than life statues of Big Fat Gus, known for his gargantuan appetite. Their job was to collect snack packaging. Each one kept on asking for more: ‘Paper here!’ His big mouth had a vacuuming engine. Whenever a visitor held waste in front of him, Big Fat Gus would suck it in and thank the generous giver. Children loved and fed him and unwittingly kept the park tidy forever. Deposits on packaging have the same effect, but without the charm.

Nudging people to behave in a certain way is fascinating.
Floor graphics with lines or footsteps can encourage us to use stairs over the escalator. A 2D playing child picture on the street reduces driving speed. A urinal with a decoy fly pictured near the drain directs the urine stream and keeps the toilet clean.

Cues rule instinct: following cues can be rewarding. Subway stairs were designed to make sounds like piano keys. Everyone prefers music and dance over a boring escalator ride.
 

READ MORE >>

 
LINKS:
 
 

Image: The Big Fat Gus waste eater that says ‘Paper here’ and ‘Thank You’ after feeding him with waste. The French anthropologist, Claude Lévi-Strauss argued that symbol systems and rituals are not reflections of social structure but are imposed on social relations to organize them.

 
 
 

5. TIME

Implicit use of the notion of time is standard procedure. Time deserves more and better. It’s about the length of time products and services are taken care of; the time they’re expected to last, as well as what happens afterwards. Things are used for a certain time, which is part of the time they exist.

Nibble on time for a while and taste where it takes you.
 
 
 


SERIOUSLY: humans are not very good at dealing with time. Estimation fails, things take longer than foreseen. Perceptions shift and time shrinks. Humans can be tricked into believing they can save time. Planning involves borrowing time from the future through self-imposed urgency. Looking at the world through a sustainability lens not only helps us 'future proof' our supply chain, it also fuels innovation.

Sustainability is often thought of as a long-term goal (i.e. a more sustainable world), while sustainable development refers to the many processes and pathways to achieve it. (UNESCO)

 
 

REFURBISHMENT AND REMANUFACTURING

Refurbishment and remanufacturing are happening, but only on a modest scale. They are like repair, but as business-to-business operations, they are more complex.

Refurbishment requires more extended design preparation. Access is required, but in this case, not lay access. Clearly design the borderline between expertise and amateurism.

For professional disassembly you may need uncommon tools.
Old components must be replaceable. New components must be compatible. Prepare for future components. They will probably be smaller and more efficient. Energy input may evolve. Monitor changes and failures.

Remanufacturing goes one step deeper. Products are stripped to their core and rebuilt to be as good as new. Consider standardization and compatibility; consider parts harvesting and reuse.

Strategic company commitment is needed to make remanufacturing a success; it’s a long-haul process. The old and wise must compete with the new. Time and again, remanufacturing and refurbishment have become a sustainable and a commercial success.

This is how you arrive at products that last.
 

READ MORE >>

 
LINKS:
 
 

Hundreds of thousands of outdated phones are discarded each day. The Fairphone was designed so that the primary expensive electronics, which don’t evolve as rapidly as the phone’s other components, are grouped together in a single module. Other modules can be replaced or upgraded. Below: Outdated real estate isn’t demolished, but is stripped down and refurbished to avoid the destruction of capital and construction materials.

 
 
 

6. RECYCLING

Recycling is not the panacea to get us from here to circularity. It is, however, the final level of the way back to continuation of use.
The most important design quality is the potential to salvage used materials. Track ’m down and catch ’m, or we will be left with good for nothing, dirty soup.
 
 
 


How 6 Million Pounds Of Electronic Waste Gets Recycled A Month. Only 17% of electronic waste is recycled. That’s because devices aren’t designed to be recycled. They’re full of tiny, toxic materials that are hard and expensive to break down. But if extracted safely, those materials could mean big money for e-recyclers like Sims Lifecycle Services. We visit Sims’ Tennessee recycling facility to find out why e-waste is getting harder to deal with.

If it can’t be reduced, reused, repaired, rebuilt, refurbished, refinished, resold, recycled, or composted, then it should be restricted, redesigned or removed from production. (Pete Seeger, Folk Singer & Social Activist)

 
 

KEEP IT SEPARABLE AND TRACEABLE

The main rule, in the widest sense is: Don’t mess things up, literally. This implies an obvious but not yet conventional principle: Keep materials separable and traceable for years on end.

Thus, a new angle for functional integration is: it’s not necessarily smart to try and put all you need into one super material that you’d then have to incinerate after use. Always consider what happens in the long run.

Design for recycling boils down to:

• Make high-value or hazardous components easy to access and remove.
• Use recycled materials that can be recycled.
• Use material combinations and connections that will separate during recycling (no glue).
• Don’t use hazardous substances.

Sustainability will keep you off the streets for a lifetime.
 

READ MORE >>

 
LINKS:
 
 

Right image: Swiss comedian Ursus Wehrli loves organisation in the extreme. In his book ‘The Art of Clean Up’, Wehrli arranges our chaotic world into neat rows sorted by colour, size, shape or type.

 
 
 

7. BETTER BUSINESS

Watch our supply chains continuously extending over continents and oceans. They’re getting ever more entangled.

They have also become increasingly vulnerable to disasters: climate changes, water disappears, toxin levels rise, life becomes extinct.

People take wrong turns, and serious accidents happen. We engage in conflicts and mis-underestimate the side-effects of our actions. We know all this. Risks increase. Unveiling itself is the riskiness of scale. Risk is probability x impact. Both are on the increase.

Companies need to prepare for this. Increasingly they do so by embracing principles of sustainability.
 
 
 


For more than 30 years, Jenny Holzer's name has stood for a conceptual art that questions our perceptions and the way we are influenced by media and politics. Holzer has made LED signs her trademark. These text displays, designed to captivate and sway passersby, have been repurposed by Holzer since the early 1980s. Jenny Holzer's work demonstrates that while art may not be able to change the world, it can heighten our awareness of what surrounds us.

One of the glories and terrors of working in public is that you do see if your output means anything to anyone. (Jenny Holzer)

 
 

SET AMBITIOUS GOALS

Here we have the World Business Council for Sustainable Development. This is a community of over 200 leading businesses, led by a CEO. They work as a collective ‘to accelerate the system transformations needed for a net zero, nature positive, and more equitable future’.

They ask their members to adhere to 5 criteria:

1. Set an ambition to reach net zero greenhouse gas emissions, no later than 2050 and have a science-informed plan to achieve it.

2. Set ambitious, short and mid-term environmental goals that contribute to nature and biodiversity recovery by 2050.

3. Have a policy in place to respect human rights and declare support for the UN Guiding Principles on Business and Human Rights.

4. Declare support for inclusion, equality, diversity, and the elimination of any form of discrimination.

5. Operate at the highest level of transparency by disclosing material sustainability.

Criteria such as these also challenge designers. They can explore new partnerships, refocus creativity, and search for new areas for development of products, services, materials, and processes. Net-zero greenhouse emissions are the classic goal. Ways to contribute to biodiversity recovery is as yet uncharted territory.
 

READ MORE >>

 
LINKS:
 
 

In 2019, about 43.1 billion tons of CO2 from human activities were emitted into the atmosphere. Global livestock contributed 7.1 billion tons. Reductions of 55?fore 2030 are needed to limit the rise in global temperature to 1.5 degrees.

 
 
 

8. SUSTAINING SOFTWARE

The sheer amount of data that our systems process is far larger than humanity can ever come to terms with. Energy consumption is soaring, and this is only gradually getting noticed. Data centers are a silent bunch.

Interrelationship between hardware and software power is driving an upward running spiral of increasing deceptive perfection. It’s not that complicated to dampen these effects, all it needs is care.
 
 
 


In the coming years, artificial intelligence is probably going to change your life— and likely the entire world. But people have a hard time agreeing on exactly how AI will affect our society. Can we build AI systems that help us fix the world? Or are we doomed to a robotic takeover? Explore the limitations of artificial intelligence and the possibility of creating human-compatible technology. This video is based on interview excerpts from the Radio Davos Podcast. The episode is called, ‘The promises and perils of AI’ (Stuart Russell on Radio Davos)

A continuation of the current trends in AI capacity and adoption are set to lead to NVIDIA shipping 1.5 million AI server units per year by 2027. These 1.5 million servers, running at full capacity, would consume at least 85.4 terawatt-hours of electricity annually—more than what many small countries use in a year, according to the new assessment. (scientific American)

 
 

RED HOT DATA

Take a selfie and put it online. There’s a selfie index, based on careful assumptions. One selfie contains 2 MB. The index is the amount of CO2 emissions per MB. The emissions from 10 selfies on the internet equal driving 1 kilometer with a normal car. Consider this: in 2020 we humans shot 93 million selfies a day worldwide. That’s just selfies – a fragment of all software.

Life without software just isn’t life. Software is in an intimate embrace with hardware. Gee up! The hardware gains speed and capacity. Eat! Software employs it all and wants more.

Growing data swarms need a soaring amount of energy. Software has a huge impact on energy consumption; it determines what servers and storage drivers do. The more they do, the more cooling they need.

Cooling is undercover inefficiency.

The University of Cambridge estimates that the Bitcoin network swallows 126 Terawatt-hours (TWh). Switzerland swallows half of that; soon it will be entire Brazil.

Artificial Intelligence is just as hot. The wasteful approach of throwing more computing power at a problem to refine results has been dubbed ‘red AI’.
 

READ MORE >>

 
LINKS:
 
 

Waste heat recovery from data centers is bound to play an important role for the energy transition, as almost 100% of the electricity supply to a data center is transformed into heat. The old server population is estimated to consume 96% of server energy but to deliver only 4% of performance capacity. Below: Since 2010, the number of internet users worldwide has doubled, while global internet traffic has expanded 15-fold (source: IEA).

 
 
 

9. MEASURING EFFECTS

When you’ve made the proverbial difference, you need proof. The main method for providing proof is Life Cycle Assessment (LCA). This is easier for technology than for social circumstances.

LCA works best when comparisons with predecessors are available.

Results heavily depend on assumptions. That’s OK; design always does. The point is to be aware of this and to be transparent.
 
 
 


Life Cycle Assessment concerns the environmental impact of a product or service over all stages of its life cycle. LCA procedures are documented in an official standard (ISO 14040). They take four steps: Goal and Scope, Life Cycle Inventory, Impact Assessment and Interpretation. Introductory lecture from the TU Delft faculty of industrial design engineering on life cycle assessment (LCA), focusing on ‘fast track’ or scoping LCA - what is it for, what does it measure (and not measure), and how to use it in early stage design.

Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) has emerged as an essential and widely recognized framework to understand and measure the environmental, social and economic attributes of a product, material or process. Sustainability is responding to basic needs and fostering a better quality of life while minimizing the use of natural resources, pollutants, emissions, and waste over the life cycle of the product or process so as not to jeopardize the needs of further generations.

 
 

INDICATORS, TARGETS, GOALS

How can we aim for a more sustainable future, and what do we need for that? Enter: Sustainability Indicators, or Targets, or Goals.

Many companies and governments use them.
The European Commission wants Europe to reduce greenhouse gas emissions to at least 55 percent below 1990 levels by 2030.
The Sustainable Development Goals come with lists of targets (#Envision2030).

You can develop your own personal targets and goals. Designers have the advantage that they can visualize and embody this aspirational sustainable future.

At least as important as defining and maintaining indicators is, of course, acting upon them.
 

READ MORE >>

 
LINKS:
 
 

The Paris Agreement is a legally binding international treaty on climate change. It was adopted by 196 Parties at COP 21 in Paris, on 12 December 2015. Its goal is to limit global warming to 1.5 degrees Celsius in 2050, compared to pre-industrial levels. The Climate protection index in 2020 revealed that no country is on track.

 
 
 

10. CELEBRATE

It’s quite possible that you can find a counterargument to just about every point made in this book.

Great!

Question everything. Don’t blindly follow dogmatic discourse on what should be. Instead, know your own mind and keep it open to what could be.
 
 
 


Mexican artist and designer Pedro Reyes is interested in how an object is able to trigger an activity and how an activity can result in an object. Projects that bridge the gap between art and psychology. He uses sculpture, architecture, video, performance and participation. His works aims to increase individual or collective agency in social, environmental, political or educational situations.

My works and designs combine games involving interaction, psychology and sculpture with a therapeutic aim and outcome. Like the Museum of Hypothetical Lifetimes, which encourages people to become curators and exhibition designers for their own lives. I believe projects like this opens a space for human connection. (Pedro Reyes)

 
 

HOW TO CONTINUE

Take baby steps. Start, for instance, by using recycled plastic in just one component of your product. This may, by the way, be much more difficult than you think. Even such a small step will bring you a wealth of knowledge and new contacts.

Prioritize wisely: If your product is an energy-guzzler, don’t focus on recycled plastics; try to find energy efficient solutions instead. When in doubt about priorities, use fast-track life cycle assessment, or ask an expert.

Strategize: Engaging with sustainability concerns the long run. Include the future in your projects and continue to do so. They’re never really ‘done’ and require constant maintenance. Keep an eye out for changing legislation, rebound effects, new technologies and opportunities. Lobby for change, if necessary.

Negotiate: Designing for sustainability is always a negotiation, with possible solutions emerging and dynamically changing over time. Any solution will be fraught with unintended side effects, just like medicines. Think in terms of treatment, like a GP does. Do your level best, monitor, and learn. One step forward, no matter how modest, is a step in the right direction. Celebrate!
 

READ MORE >>

 
LINKS:
 
 

The Design for Sustainability Survival Guide: Each of the 192 pages offers essential advice on the fundamentals of design for sustainability.

 



 
DESIGN FOR SUSTAINABILITY SURVIVAL GUIDE
Each page of this book provides short and well-illustrated opportunities to help you participate in design for sustainability projects.

Authors: Conny Bakker, Ed van Hinte, Yvo Zijlstra
Paperback with flaps: 160 pages full colour
Price: € 19,99 / size: 19 x 13,5 cm
ISBN 97 890 6369 639 9
BIS Publishers